330-867-5309
Quick Search
Join Sign In
Buy Sell Realtors & Company
  • Contact Us
    Careers
    Reviews
    Our Story
    Leadership Team
  • Offices

    Want more information on our offices? Select an office below.


  • Find A Realtor

    Already working with an Realtor or have one in mind? Search below.


Communities
Services Cash Advantage
Quick Home Search
All Regions Northeast Ohio Columbus & Central Ohio Cincinnati & Northern Kentucky
Cutler Blog

Cincinnati & Northern Kentucky | 93 Posts
Columbus & Central Ohio | 118 Posts
Explore Ohio | 98 Posts
Home Inspiration | 4 Posts
LoLo Gifts | 34 Posts
Northeast Ohio | 197 Posts
Real Estate | 105 Posts
Uncategorized | 1 Posts

Subscribe and receive email notifications of new blog posts.




English

Never Miss a Post!

SUBSCRIBE BY EMAIL

Search Northeast Ohio, Columbus, Cincinnati & Northern Kentucky Properties

Quick Home Search

Popular Posts

4 Reasons Your House Is High on Every Buyer's Wish List This Season What's Motivating Homeowners To Move Right Now How Home Equity May Help You Buy Your Next Home in Cash Today's Biggest Housing Market Myths Don't Let Student Loans Hold You Back from Homeownership

 

December
3

December 3rd, 2021 by

Toy Stores Around Ohio - Cutler Real Estate

There's nothing quite like seeing the joy in a child's eyes when they receive a Christmas gift they really love. When you choose to skip the big-box stores and support local instead, you'll help keep the shopkeeper's dreams alive as well. 

If you're ready to start your holiday shopping soon, you'll be glad to know that there are some great locally owned toy stores in Northeast Ohio, Columbus, and Cincinnati. Here's a look at some of our favorites.

Smartickles Toy Store

986 Medina Rd. Suite A, Medina, OH 44256

If you're looking for fun and educational holiday gifts, you'll definitely want to pay a visit to Smartickles Toy Store. This family-owned and operated business has been around since 1976. They carry all of the most popular developmental toy brands including LEGO, Colorforms, Melissa & Doug, and more.

Everything is priced very affordably and they carry a huge inventory of items. There are also lots of cool options for "big kids" too, so you may want to pay a visit even if you're not shopping for little ones.

PLAYmatters Toys

30789 Pinetree Rd., Pepper Pike, OH 44124

PLAYmatters Toys was voted Best Toy Store in the 2021 annual Northeast Ohio Parent Choice Awards — for good reason. This specialty shop sells premier-quality toys, dolls, games, and puzzles from some of the best toymakers around the world. 

Not only will you find some great gifts here, but they also offer free gift wrapping with a selection of fun papers, so you can present the special child in your life with a beautifully wrapped gift without any hassle. 

Do you want to make gift giving easy for family and friends? You can also go to PLAYmatters and create a wish list for your child. This takes the guesswork out of it and you won't have to worry about returning gifts that aren't quite right!

Your Toy Connection

238 W. Main St., Ravenna, OH 44266

At Your Toy Connection, you'll find a huge selection of both modern and vintage toys. They have everything from toys that were popular in the 1960s to current items. While the inventory changes regularly, you'll likely find lots of Transformers, Star Wars items, POP collectibles, and more.

You can count on Your Toy Connection to offer excellent prices and their friendly staff is always happy to help. Whether you're looking for a special collectible piece or you just want to look around and see what strikes your fancy, you'll love spending time here.   

Sir Troy's Toy Kingdom

1180 S. Main St., North Canton, OH 44720

Sir Troy's Toy Kingdom is known for carrying high-quality, imagination-powered toys for both kids and adults who are kids at heart. This is one of the best places to get your hands on hard-to-find LEGO sets as well as items like MEGA BLOKS, Masterpiece Puzzles, the full line of Breyer Horses, COBI Military Sets, and more. 

In addition to the North Canton store, you'll also find locations in Medina and Solon as well as a robust online store. This makes it easy to shop local for your holiday gifts no matter where you're located. 

Dreamland

1239 Polaris Pkwy., Columbus, OH 43240

Founded in 2011, Dreamland is one of the most popular toy stores in Columbus. They carry a large selection of toy brands like Disney, Ty, Melisssa & Doug, Mattel, Fisher-Price, and more. They also have a selection of Squishmallows and giant fidget pops. 

Need a deluxe scooter with LED wheels, a 3D Harry Potter puzzle, or a giant stuffed T-rex? You'll find all this and more at Dreamland! 

Big Fun Columbus

672 N. High St., Columbus, OH 43215

If you're looking for some fun stocking stuffers or vintage toys for a child who is into collecting, you'll want to check out Big Fun Columbus. They always have a super cool selection, and since they buy old toys all the time, you can find cool new stuff every time you visit. 

Coolest Toys on Earth

6840 Wooster Pike, Cincinnati, OH 45227

For rare and unique gifts for kids (and adults!), you can't go wrong with Coolest Toys on Earth. This shop almost feels more like a cool toy museum than a retail store. They carry a huge selection of rare and high-quality toys, outdoor games, puzzles, science items, building kits, toys for younger kids, and more. A gift from this store is guaranteed to be one that will get a ton of use. 

Flying Pig Toys

7723 Five Mile Rd., Cincinnati, OH 45230

Looking for a gift that will last a lifetime? Check out the high-quality wooden toys at Flying Pig Toys. They carry many unique brands and have a constantly evolving selection. In addition to toys, you'll also find a wide variety of stackers and tons of books ranging from educational to silly. They even have a selection of pop-up baby books. 

Flying Pig Toys offers a rewards program and the ability to make a wish list. This makes them a popular choice among parents in the Cincinnati area. 

House of Plastik

834 OH-125 #310, Cincinnati, OH 45245

If you have a kid (or big kid) in your life who is into vintage or collectible items, then you'll want to check out House of Plastik. They have a great selection of action figures, Transformers, My Little Pony, Star Wars items, and more. If you need some stocking stuffers, you can also get some great candy here. 

Since they buy used items, you can always find something new and exciting. And, if you need to clear out some space and make some cash, you might be able to sell a few old items before the holidays arrive. 

Santa Claus is Coming to Town! 

Where will you shop for fun items to spread Christmas cheer this year? 

Categories: Explore Ohio
Tags: Columbus OH, Holidays, Cincinnati OH, Akron OH, Canton OH, Cleveland OH, Dublin OH, Kent OH, Mantua OH, Silver Lake OH, Stow OH, Tallmadge OH, Holiday, Shop Local, Shopping, Holiday Shopping, Copley OH, Massillon OH, Medina OH, North Canton OH, Small Businesses, Over-the-Rhine OH, Hyde Park OH, Alliance OH, Hartville OH, Wooster OH, Carrollton OH, Malvern OH, Lake Mohawk OH, Beachwood OH, Bedford OH, Brecksville OH, Independence OH, Mayfield Heights OH, Middleburg Heights OH, Ohio City OH, Pepper Pike OH, Rocky River OH, Seven Hills OH, Tremont OH, Westlake OH, Avon OH, Elyria OH, Amherst OH, Brunswick OH, Wadsworth OH, Aurora OH, Garrettsville OH, Streetsboro OH, Ravenna OH, Canal Fulton OH, East Sparta OH, Jackson Township OH, Louisville OH, Magnolia OH, Navarre OH, Perry Township OH, Plain Township OH, Sandyville OH, Uniontown OH, Waynesburg OH, Barberton OH, Cuyahoga Falls OH, Fairlawn OH, Green OH, Hudson OH, Munroe Falls OH, Bolivar OH, Dover OH, New Philadelphia OH, Bexley OH, Delaware OH, Downtown Columbus OH, Galena OH, German Village OH, Lewis Center OH, Ostrander OH, Powell OH, Short North OH, Sunbury OH, Westerville OH, Lancaster OH, Fayette County OH, Blacklick OH, Canal Winchester OH, Clintonville OH, Gahanna OH, Grandview Heights OH, Grove City OH, Groveport OH, Hilliard OH, New Albany OH, Obetz OH, Reynoldsburg OH, Upper Arlington OH, Whitehall OH, Worthington OH, Granville OH, Johnstown OH, Pataskala OH, London OH, Mount Sterling OH, West Jefferson OH, Pickaway County OH, Marysville OH, Western Hills OH, West Chester OH, Union County OH, Carroll County OH, Delaware County OH, Fairfield County OH, Franklin County OH, Hamilton County OH, Licking County OH, Lorain County OH, Madison County OH, Portage County OH, Summit County OH, Tuscarawas County OH, Wayne County OH, Local Businesses
Related Markets: Akron, Alliance, Amherst, Avon, Barberton, Beachwood, Bedford, Bexley, Blacklick, Bolivar, Brecksville, Brunswick, Canal Fulton, Canal Winchester, Canton, Carroll, Carrollton, Cincinnati, Cleveland, Clintonville, Columbus, Copley, Delaware, Downtown Columbus, Dublin, Elyria, Fairfield, Fairlawn, Fayette, Franklin, Gahanna, Galena, German Village, Grandview Heights, Granville, Green, Grove City, Groveport, Hamilton, Hartville, Hilliard, Hudson, Hyde Park, Independence, Jackson Township, Johnstown, Kent, Lake Mohawk, Lancaster, Lewis Center, Licking, London, Lorain, Louisville, Madison, Magnolia, Malvern, Mantua, Marysville, Massillon, Mayfield Heights, Medina, Middleburg Heights, Mount Sterling, Munroe Falls, Navarre, New Albany, North Canton, Obetz, Ohio City, Ostrander, Over-the-Rhine, Pataskala, Pepper Pike, Perry Township, Pickaway, Plain Township, Portage, Powell, Ravenna, Reynoldsburg, Rocky River, Sandyville, Seven Hills, Short North, Silver Lake, Stow, Streetsboro, Summit, Sunbury, Tallmadge, Tremont, Tuscarawas, Union, Uniontown, Upper Arlington, Wadsworth, Wayne, Waynesburg, West Chester, West Jefferson, Western Hills, Westerville, Westlake, Whitehall, Wooster, Worthington

Login to My Homefinder

Forgot Password

Register

Pixel